Name: Fiore's Restaurant
Price range: $$

Fiore's Restaurant Information

Stepping into Fiore's Restaurant at 421 W Broadway St, New Lexington, OH 43764, immediately feels like entering a warm, inviting neighborhood eatery where the focus is all about hearty, satisfying meals and a welcoming atmosphere. The interior balances cozy charm with a touch of classic Italian flair, making it the perfect spot for families, couples, or anyone looking for a relaxed dining experience. The menu offers a well-rounded selection that highlights Italian-American favorites, from generously topped pizzas with perfectly crisp crusts to rich, flavorful pasta dishes that linger pleasantly on the palate. Patrons often rave about the lasagna, noting its comforting layers and robust seasoning, while the hand-tossed subs and calzones stand out for their fresh ingredients and satisfying portions. Beyond the traditional mains, Fiore's also delivers a variety of lighter options, including fresh salads and daily specials that rotate with seasonal ingredients, reflecting a keen attention to quality and local produce. Service tends to be attentive without feeling rushed, and many reviews highlight the friendly, personable staff who make diners feel like regulars even on a first visit. The restaurant manages a lively yet relaxed vibe, where the hum of conversation and the occasional clink of cutlery contribute to a homey, welcoming energy. Accessibility and convenience are additional pluses, with a location that’s easy to find and ample parking nearby, making it an effortless choice for both lunch breaks and evening meals. Whether stopping in for a quick bite or settling in for a leisurely dinner, the combination of thoughtfully prepared dishes, approachable menu variety, and inviting atmosphere positions Fiore's Restaurant as a standout option in New Lexington for anyone craving authentic flavors and genuine hospitality.

Business Info

What People's Say About Place

Review is mainly to help future customers on having a stress free experience. The restaurant and food, games and all of that is fine and friendly with good service. Although it is advertised in the middle of the check I would recommend that you not use the Toasttab digital payment option. While everything processed seamlessly it ultimately ended up with a stressful and unnecessary confrontation in the parking lot. I was asked to show proof that I had funds in my bank account, I was asked to show proof that the transaction was being processed in my bank account, I was asked to keep any eye on my bank account to make sure the payment goes through. I counted four staff members, the vibe was as if there was going to be some kind of trouble. When someone has PTSD, MDD, and Bipolar this type of event is damaging, not worth sixty dollars worth of food. Don’t use the digital payment option and you should be fine, witnessed others using cash and card with no hassles.

I usually stop at trotters on way back from value auto auction to get lunch.let me 1st say that i love trotters but we decided to try fiores and really glad we did.great food.we got the special.baked steak with all the trimmings. Absolutely great.the service and the greating and conservation with tim fiore was fantastic.ill definitely be eating there again

I am down at Fiores so often that the workers consider it my real home. They have amazing food and staff, but the bowling alley is very out of date and could definitely be renovated. 90% of the time the lanes either break down or your ball doesn't come back. all though the price for bowling is equal to the condition of the lanes, the quality is poor and this causes our high school teams to suffer when traveling to other matches. Over all, Great place to eat and have fun, but the bowling alley needs some severe make overs and renovations for the good of the community.

I always have my kids' birthday parties here and they are the best!

We tried for the first time yesterday. Super friendly staff, they made us feel SO welcome. My fiancé liked his meal (the cod, hush puppies and something else). I had the fettuccine Alfredo and wasn’t super impressed, but I would love to go back and try something different. Definitely a small hometown feel. We loved that.

We was just passing through and decided to have some home cooking for lunch. We was pleasantly surprised about the amount of food for the price not to mention how fresh the food was. I had the pork tenderloin and onion rings, words cannot express how delicious my meal was. We recommend this place for anyone looking for some down home cooking good food.

Best family in town affordable bowling and great food. They go out of their way to sponsor their youth for sports and do so much for their bowlers. 100% love coming here

Fiore's restaurant is a romantic semi casual dining experience. Awesome steak on the menu. Anything you could want is on the menu and service is respectful, courteous and efficient. Restrooms are clean. A great selection of beverages as well. Just a terrific all around experience every time I visit

Fiore's Restaurant